How to Sell to Us
Selling your trading cards to CardFair is fast, fair, and simple. Follow these steps to get the best price for your collection.
Browse our Buylist
Check our buylist to see which cards we're currently buying and at what prices. Hotlist cards earn you a bonus of up to 150% of the normal buylist rate.
View Buylist →Submit your cards
Add cards you want to sell to your sell list. You can search by card name, set, or scan the card barcode. Once you're done, submit your sell request with your contact details.
Start Selling →We review & confirm
Our team reviews your submission and confirms the final offer within 1–2 business days. We'll contact you via email with a confirmed price for each card.
Ship your cards
Once you accept the offer, pack your cards securely and ship them to our address. We recommend using a tracked service. We cover return shipping if we can't accept a card.
Get paid
Once we receive and verify your cards, we'll process your payment within 1 business day. Choose between bank transfer or store credit (store credit gets you an extra 10% bonus!).
💰 Payment Options
Bank Transfer
Processed within 1 business day of card verification. Standard buylist prices apply.
Store Credit +10% BONUS
Receive an instant 10% bonus on top of your buylist offer. Use it to buy more cards!
Frequently Asked Questions
What condition do cards need to be in?
We accept cards in Near Mint (NM), Lightly Played (LP), and Moderately Played (MP) condition. Cards in Heavily Played (HP) or Damaged condition may be accepted at a reduced rate or declined. Check our Condition Guide for details.
How do I pack my cards safely?
We recommend sleeving each card individually, placing them in a rigid top-loader, and wrapping in bubble wrap inside a padded envelope or small box. Include your order confirmation number inside the package.
How long does payment take?
Bank transfers are processed within 1 business day of us verifying your cards. Store credit is instant once we approve your order.
What if you decline some of my cards?
If we can't accept a card (wrong condition, no longer on buylist), we'll return it to you free of charge with an explanation.
Do you accept bulk/common cards?
Currently we focus on singles on our buylist. Bulk submissions are not available yet, but we're working on it — stay tuned!